Apr
17th

Even the Big Boys forget Usability!

Happy New Year! Marketing Technology finds and reports on the latest technology that will enable your business to effectively market to your audience, for acquisition or retention strategies. Subscribe now the Marketing Technology Blog RSS feed or to the Marketing Technology Email to have new content sent directly to your inbox. You'll also find my other business blog helpful, Social Media Domination.

I wanted to write a short note on some frustrating usability issues I’ve noticed with a couple of applications.

According to Wikipedia, in human-computer interaction and computer science, usability usually refers to the elegance and clarity with which the interaction with a computer program or a web site is designed.

The first one that I’ll provide is actually a Usability issue with the Google home page. If you add the Google Reader component to the Google home page, it works quite nicely. There is; however, one glaring issue: the ‘mark all is read’ link is located directly below the link to open Google Reader.

Google Home Page Reader

A handful of times now, I’ve clicked the wrong link and all of my feeds automatically went to a status that they’ve been read. This is terrible usability. I’d encourage Google to move this link FAR away from any other links.

The second example is Microsoft Entourage, where the Delete button for an email is directly next to the Junk Email button. Microsoft Entourage is like Outlook for OSX, but it does not have any options to move the buttons around. As a result, I’ve accidentally added valid emails to my Junk Email folder. To undo that, I have to undo any Junk Email rule, find the email in my Junk Email folder, and then move it back to my Inbox. Arrgh!

Microsoft Entourage

I’m one of those guys that loves to organize and compartmentalize everything within an application. I believe both of these are examples where organizing components made sense logically - but not procedurally. It’s important to understand how users are actually using your application so that you can stop inadvertent mistakes through poor component layout.

Contrast this to WordPress, who does a fantastic job of separating components that don’t belong together. Notice the Save and Continue Editing and Save buttons at the top (which is the base of the post form) and the Delete this Post button at the very bottom on the left side… far, far away from each other.

WordPress Usability

Great job, WordPress!

Do you have examples of terrible Usability issues with applications you use?

RSS feed | Trackback URI

6 Comments »

Comment by engtech
2007-04-18 00:37:28

little known fact: I’m the reason why the delete button turns red.

because I don’t know how to read the difference between delete and save :(

Comment by Douglas Karr
2007-04-18 15:14:39

Or dark gray for those colorblind folks. ;)
 
 
Comment by Thor Schrock
2007-04-18 09:52:56

Actually, if you use Wordpress’ free hosting service with IE7 and you try to expand the “Optional Excerpt” section, it does not fully expand. This might be a glitch more than a useability problem, but never the less, it can be annoying.
 
Comment by Wes Bos
2007-04-18 10:57:53

Anything on myspace.
Comment by Douglas Karr
2007-04-18 15:14:03

Wes, that one made me cough and laugh out loud. You’re absolutely right!
 
 
2007-04-19 04:33:43

[...] Non dimenticate l’usabilit The Marketing Technology Blog ci ricorda che l’usabilità di un sito è importante e ci consiglia come fare per avere un sito moderno senza rinunciare agli standard (tags: usabilit usability webdesign web css) [...]
 
Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

My Comment Policy: I moderate comments. Please be patient:

  • Spam will happily be destroyed.
  • Use your real name, not some keywords. Otherwise it will be destroyed.
  • Mean comments aren't necessary. If I don't post them I will reply personally to let you know why.
  • Lewd comments will be edited, I don't want my readers leaving because of offensive content.
Great debate, criticism and colorful commentary is always appreciated and approved!